INKIND: What first drew you into the kitchen, and what continues to inspire you today?
DONNELLY: I grew up in the pre–Food Network era, watching the celebrity chefs of the time on TV—mostly on PBS in the ’80s. Chefs like Martin Yan (Yan Can Cook), Julia Child, and Justin Wilson’s Louisiana cooking really sparked my interest at a young age.
Outside the kitchen, we spent a lot of time fishing and hunting, so the entire process—harvesting an animal, processing it, and cooking it—had a big influence on me later in my career. That experience gave me an early understanding of seasonality and why certain ingredients are so special when they’re available at specific times of the year.
I was also drawn to the athleticism of cooking—the movement, focus, and energy required, and how all of that affects the dish, the service, and the team. And honestly, I loved the personalities of chefs from that era. They were artists, individuals with grit and passion. I wanted to be that—something different, something driven.
INKIND: From sourcing ingredients to building your team, what principles guide your approach?
DONNELLY: When sourcing ingredients, I pull from a wide array of influences and take a global approach to food—Mediterranean, Asian, classic French. I let seasonal, fresh ingredients pave the way for the dish to shine. Everything should be well-seasoned, well-prepared, and thoughtfully handled at every step.
That same philosophy carries over to building a team. When I look at a cook or someone just starting their career, I ask: what are they good at? What are they passionate about? Just like an ingredient or a component of a dish, how do they become a part of the organization, and how do they strengthen the overall team?
INKIND: For a first-time guest, what are the must-order dishes that capture the spirit of your restaurants?
DONNELLY: As the chef/owner of three completely different concepts with very different menus, this is a bit of a challenge—so I’ll share what I personally order when I dine at each.
RockCreek Seafood & Spirits: I like to start with the baked oysters, cauliflower salad, shrimp and grits, or the grilled octopus with olive aioli, roasted tomatoes, and cannellini beans.
For mains, I love the Chilean sea bass with warm herb salad, crispy shallots, and dill, or the jerk-marinated swordfish with yucca frita, bacon-onion mojo, and coriander.
FlintCreek Cattle Co.: Aside from our butcher burger (only available at happy hour), the warm duck salad with lentils, bitter greens, Banyuls vinegar, and Délice de Bourgogne cheese is a must. The venison pâté with hazelnuts, English pickle relish, pickled shallots, and radishes is another favorite.
We’re definitely known for our steaks, so splitting a tomahawk ribeye with all the sauces and a couple of good friends is always a win. In winter, my favorite dish is the rosemary–peppercorn-crusted venison loin with parsnip purée, brandy and cranberry gastrique, and fried sage.
Bar Sur Mer: I always start with one of our signature gin and tonics, followed by the squid and white bean salad with fresh chervil, wood-fired sardines with persillade and lemon, or the steak tartare with olive vinaigrette and potato crisps. Finish with a glass of sweet, mineral-kissed txakoli and our warm Basque cheesecake with yuzu marmalade.